Advanced searchCitation search
Skip main navigation
Close Drawer MenuOpen Drawer Menu
History of Medicine15 January 1997

The Pre-Flexnerian Reports: Mark Twain's Criticism of Medicine in the United States

    Author, Article, and Disclosure Information
    https://doi.org/10.7326/0003-4819-126-2-199701150-00012

    Abstract

    By the time Mark Twain was born, in 1835, the political forces of Jacksonian democracy had created an era of unregulated medical practice in the United States.Licensure laws were almost nonexistent, and any citizen could practice medicine. Regular (“allopathic”) Medicine was competing with at least two dozen other sects, including homeopathic, botanical, and hydropathic medicine. Although allopathy presented itself as the “scientific” branch of medicine and proclaimed the practices of the other sects to be “quackery,” its therapies were aggressive and toxic and had no proven advantage over the treatments used by competitors. Through the efforts of the American Medical Association (AMA), allopathic medicine eliminated its competition by promoting the reestablishment of licensure laws in the late 1800s. In a continuation of the same endeavor, the AMA sought to identify weak and inadequate medical schools and commissioned Abraham Flexner to write the famous Flexner report of 1910 (the year of Mark Twain's death).

    Twain, an insightful political observed and social critic who was familiar with the competing medical systems and the medical politics of the 19th century, questioned the wisdom of limiting patients' medical options.He doubted the competence and intentions of physicians as a group even as he maintained confidence in the abilities of his own physicians. He was critical of the empirical medical practices used during his youth, but he saw hope in the new scientific orientation of medicine in the early 20th century. Twain's commentaries provide a unique perspective on pre-Flexnerian medicine in the United States.

    References

    • 1. Felts JH. Abraham Flexner and medical education in North Carolina. N C Med J. 1995; 56:534-40. Google Scholar
    • 2. Berliner HS. A larger perspective on the Flexner report. Int J Health Serv. 1975; 5:573-92. Google Scholar
    • 3. Ebert RH. Flexner's model and the future of medical education. Acad Med. 1992; 67:737-42. Google Scholar
    • 4. Friedlander WJ. Mark Twain, social critic, and his image of the doctor. Ann Intern Med. 1972; 77:1007-10. Google Scholar
    • 5. Ravin JG. Mark Twain in Ohio. The novelist's visits with some of his medical opinions. Ohio Med. 1989; 85:858-63. Google Scholar
    • 6. Meltzer M. Mark Twain Himself. New York: Wings Books; 1993:288. Google Scholar
    • 7. Twain M. The comedy those extraordinary twins. In: Teacher L, ed. The Unabridged Mark Twain. Philadelphia: Running Pr; 1979:135-84. Google Scholar
    • 8. Twain M. Dinner speech. In: Fatout P, ed. Mark Twain Speaking. lowa City, IA: Univ of lowa Pr; 1976:631-6. Google Scholar
    • 9. Rasmussen RK. Mark Twain A to Z: The Essential Reference to His Life and Writings. New York: Facts on File; 1995:299-300. Google Scholar
    • 10. Twain M. Notebooks and journals. v. III (1883-1891). Berkeley: Univ of California Pr; 1979:415. Google Scholar
    • 11. Twain M. A Majestic literary fossil, In: Neider C, ed. The Complete Humorous Sketches and Tales of Mark Twain. Garden City, NY: doubleday; 1961:532-42. Google Scholar
    • 12. Twain M. The Autobiography of Mark Twain. New York: Harper & Row; 1975:11-2. Google Scholar
    • 13. Twain M. Remarks on osteopathy. In: Fatout P, ed. Mark Twain Speaking. Iowa City, IA: Univ of lowa Pr; 1976:384-8. Google Scholar
    • 14. King LS. Medicine in the USA: historical vignettes. III. Medical sects and their influence. JAMA. 1982; 248:1221-4. Google Scholar
    • 15. Legan MS. Hydropathy in America: a nineteenth century panacea. Bull Hist Med. 1971; 45:267-80. Google Scholar
    • 16. Osler W. The Principles and Practice of Medicine: Designed for the Use of Practitioners and Students of Medicine. New York: D. Appleton; 1892:530. Google Scholar
    • 17. Twain M. Dinner speech. In: Fatout P, ed. Mark Twain Speaking. Iowa City, IA: Univ of lowa Pr; 1976:429-31. Google Scholar
    • 18. Weiss HB, Kemble HR. The great American water-cure craze: a history of hydropathy in the United States. Trenton, UJ: Past Times Pr; 1967:18. Google Scholar
    • 19. Twain M. Christian Science and the book of Mrs. Eddy. In: Budd LJ, ed. Mark Twain: Collected Tales, Sketches, Speeches, and Essays 1891-1910. New York: The Library of America; 1992:371-89. Google Scholar
    • 20. Twain M. The autobiography of Mark Twain. New York: Harper & Row; 1975:200-1. Google Scholar
    • 21. King LS. Medicine in the USA: historical vignettes. XX. The Flexner report of 1910. JAMA. 1984; 251:1079-86. Google Scholar
    • 22. Hudson HP. Abraham Flexner in perspective: American medical education 1865-1910. Bull Hist Med. 1972; 46:545-61. Google Scholar
    • 23. Twain M. Official physic. In: Budd LJ, ed. Mark Twain: Collected Tales, Sketches, Speeches, and Essays 1852-1890. New York: The Library of America; 1992:228-30. Google Scholar
    • 24. Salmon JW, Berliner HS. Health policy implications of the hilistic health movement. J. Health Polit Policy Law. 1980; 5:535-53. Google Scholar
    • 25. Budd LJ. Notes In: Budd LJ, ed. Mark Twain: Collected Tales, Sketches, Speeches, and Essays 1852-1890. New York. The Library of America; 1992:1025-71. Google Scholar
    • 26. Berliner HS. New light on the Flexner report: notes on the AMA-Carnegie Foundation background. Bull Hist Med. 1977; 51:603-9. Google Scholar
    • 27. Meyer CT, Price A. Osteopathic medicine: a call for reform. J Am Osteopath Assoc. 1993; 93:473-85. Google Scholar
    • 28. Brashear MM. Dr. Still and Mark Twain. J Am Osteopath Assoc. 1973; 68:113-7. Google Scholar
    • 29. Rasmussen RK. Mark Twain A to Z: The Essential Reference to His Life and Writings. New York: Facts on File; 1995:269. Google Scholar
    • 30. Kreisberg R. Clinical problem-solving. We blew it. N Engl J Med. 1995; 332:945-9. Google Scholar
    • 31. Twain M. Letters. v. 4 (1870-1871). Berkeley: Univ of California Pr; 1995: 333. Google Scholar
    • 32. Twain M. Dr Loeb's incredible discovery. In Budd LJ, ed. Mark Twain: Collected Tales, Sketches, Speeches, and Essays 1891-1190. New York: The Library of America; 1992:648-51. Google Scholar
    Previous
    Next

    Submit a Comment

    Contributors must reveal any conflict of interest. Comments are moderated. Please see our information for authorsregarding comments on an Annals publication.
    *All comments submitted after October 1, 2021 and selected for publication will be published online only.
    Cancel